Welcome to Carmella's
Nestled in the heart of Appleton, Wisconsin, Carmella's is more than just an Italian restaurant; it’s a culinary journey steeped in tradition and passion. With a focus on authentic flavors and fresh ingredients, Carmella's offers a diverse menu that includes vegetarian delights and classic antipasti, like seared sea scallops and butternut squash tortelloni. The ambiance is casual yet classy, perfect for families and groups alike, and features outdoor seating for enjoying delightful meals al fresco. With exceptional service, a variety of payment options, and a welcoming atmosphere, Carmella’s is a dining destination that truly embodies the Italian spirit of community and hospitality.
-
716 N Casaloma Dr Appleton, WI 54913 United States Hotline: (920) 882-4044
Welcome to Carmella's, a delightful Italian eatery nestled in the heart of Appleton, Wisconsin. As a food reviewer for Restaurant World, it brings me immense pleasure to introduce you to a restaurant that beautifully captures the essence of Italian cuisine while offering a modern twist. The address, 716 N Casaloma Dr, beckons not only locals but also food enthusiasts from afar, promising an unforgettable dining experience.
Carmella's stands out for its commitment to quality and variety, featuring a menu that caters to all dietary preferences. With numerous vegetarian options, this restaurant ensures that everyone finds something to savor. The ambiance strikes a balance between classy and casual, making it an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. Whether you're planning a family lunch, a dinner date, or a celebratory feast, the atmosphere is perfectly inviting.
- Reservations: Recommended for busy times, ensuring you don't have to wait to enjoy exquisite Italian flavors.
- Options for Takeout and Delivery: Enjoy your favorite dishes from the comfort of your home.
- Accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible with outdoor seating for those sunny days.
- Catering Services: Perfect for larger groups and special events.
- Kid-Friendly: A welcoming environment for families, with options that delight the little ones.
The menu at Carmella's is a culinary adventure, starting with fresh and vibrant salads. The Roasted Beet Insalata is a personal favorite, boasting a delightful combination of textures and flavors with its creamy ricotta and zesty white balsamic vinaigrette. For those with a penchant for antipasti, the Butternut Squash Tortelloni is a must-try. Its rich brown butter sauce paired with crispy prosciutto is reminiscent of a warm embrace, transporting you to the heart of Italy.
Moving on to the pasta, each dish is crafted with precision. The inviting aromas from the Chili Grilled Shrimp plate leave you yearning for more, with its perfect balance of spice and creaminess. Meanwhile, the Prince Edward Island Mussels in a savory tomato broth sings notes of the sea, offering a gently comforting experience that's hard to forget.
Carmella's prides itself on providing a range of wines and beers to complement your meal, alongside enticing happy hour specials that make the visit even more enjoyable. Additionally, the capability to support your furry friends with outdoor seating is a charming bonus for dog lovers.
In conclusion, Carmella's doesn't just serve meals; it creates a delightful dining experience steeped in Italian tradition and modern excellence. This gem of a restaurant invites you to savor the flavors, enjoy excellent service, and take part in a community that thrives on culinary passion. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, make it a point to indulge at Carmella's—you won't be disappointed!
Ask for the Napoleon. Its not on the menu but its delicious. Fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, balsamic, and basil. Great ambiance. Very cozy and romantic. ...
Ok. So I must start with the fact that I have not yet been to Carmellas. I however am a server at an Italian restaurant and I had the great pleasure of waiting on the owners of this restaurant. I will say that they were the most pleasant ...
I would just like to say I am never disappointed here. Im a huge Italian connoisseur which also means Im hard to please, this is the only restaurant in the valley where the food has satisfied the basil shaped hole in my heart. ...
Overall, for phenomenal experience this time. The service was exceptional. The food was amazing and the flavors were all on point. Very happy with everything and the experience. The restaurant was not too loud this time so it was quite comfortable to have conversations. I look forward to going back again
We absolutely loved this restaurant! Its an awesome place for an excellent dinner. The staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient. My husband had clams for an appetizer, and spaghetti with meatballs in marinara.He loved everything. ...
Honestly, my favorite treat yourself restaurant in the area! My mother and I got the seared sea scallops appetizer to share, and the scallops ...
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. A friend recommended Carmellas and being such a fan of Italian food my husband and I decided to make reservations and check it out. It was well worth the two ...
I really appreciated the great service while dining at Carmellas. They have a very cozy atmosphere, but the lighting could have been a little brighter as it was hard to study the menu. They have a variety of beers and wines, no liquor. ...